OnlyKashmir.in
Sarwar Kawoosa
Condemnations after every seizure mean little unless the government dismantles the networks behind the illegal trade, strengthens inspections and holds those responsible accountable.
The return of the rotten-meat scare in Kashmir is not merely another food safety incident. It is a disturbing reminder of how little seems to have changed despite last year’s scandal, widespread public outrage, official assurances and promises of strict action. The seizure of nearly 2,000 kilograms of rotten buffalo meat at Budgam Railway Station, reportedly transported from Delhi without adequate refrigeration or ice, raises a fundamental question: How does such a dangerous consignment continue to find its way into Kashmir despite the lessons of the past?
More disturbing than the seizure itself is the society’s familiar reaction. As soon as such a scandal comes to light, statements of condemnation begin pouring in from politicians, religious figures, business representatives, social activists and even individuals whose public presence is otherwise barely noticeable. Everyone appears concerned about public health, morality and the dignity of Kashmir. But where was this concern when the illegal trade was operating? Why does our collective conscience awaken only after the damage is exposed?
Condemning an incident after it happens is easy. Preventing it requires courage, responsibility and consistent action. Those who exploit public health for personal wealth cannot be allowed to escape accountability merely because they are not directly visible in the supply chain. The entire network, including suppliers, transporters, distributors, storage operators and those knowingly facilitating the trade, must be investigated wherever evidence points to their involvement. No individual or influential business interest should be beyond scrutiny.
The government, meanwhile, must look beyond occasional raids and headline-making seizures. It needs to investigate how rotten and improperly stored meat enters Kashmir, which routes are being used, who receives these consignments and whether similar material has already reached markets, hotels, restaurants and roadside eateries. The latest seizure should trigger a comprehensive investigation into the entire supply chain rather than end with the destruction of the recovered meat and registration of an FIR.
Another troubling aspect is the unchecked proliferation of restaurants, eateries, food outlets and roadside establishments across Kashmir. In many localities, a new food outlet appears after every few minutes of walking. The expansion of the hospitality sector is not inherently problematic; it generates employment, supports tourism and creates economic opportunities. However, has the regulatory system expanded at the same pace? Are these establishments properly registered, licensed and regularly inspected? Do they have adequate refrigeration, hygienic storage facilities and traceable sources of meat and other food products? Who verifies the quality of the material being served to unsuspecting customers?
The government cannot encourage the expansion of the food and hospitality industry while treating its regulation as a secondary responsibility. Every restaurant, hotel, dhaba, cloud kitchen and food establishment must operate under clearly enforced food safety standards. Licensing should not become a one-time formality. Regular inspections, surprise checks, laboratory testing and verification of suppliers must be an integral part of the system.
Equally important is the need to strengthen monitoring at railway stations, highways, airports, warehouses and distribution centres. The latest incident demonstrates that checking one transportation route while leaving another inadequately monitored creates opportunities for illegal operators. Every incoming consignment must have verifiable documentation, proper veterinary certification and an uninterrupted cold chain wherever required. Scientific testing and traceability should replace dependence on paperwork and occasional visual inspections.
There is also a need to distinguish between unsafe imported consignments, locally slaughtered meat and processed products. Public confidence cannot be restored by creating indiscriminate suspicion about every butcher, restaurant or meat supplier. Genuine traders and businesses should not suffer because of the criminal or unethical practices of a few. The responsibility of the administration is to identify the offenders through evidence-based investigations and protect both consumers and honest businesses.
The role of religious and social institutions also deserves reflection. Kashmir frequently invokes religious values, ethical conduct and the sanctity of human life. Yet, these principles must be reflected in commercial behaviour as well. Selling rotten food for profit is not simply a violation of business regulations; it is a betrayal of public trust. Moral lectures delivered after a scandal cannot substitute for a consistent culture of honesty and accountability in everyday business dealings.
Last year’s controversy should have been a permanent warning. Yet, the recurrence of such incidents suggests that the underlying weaknesses have not been adequately addressed. The government must make public the findings of previous investigations, explain what action was taken against those responsible and identify the regulatory failures that allowed the problem to resurface. Suspended licences, registered cases and seized consignments are necessary enforcement measures, but they cannot be the sole indicators of success.
Kashmir’s food industry cannot survive on public trust alone if that trust is repeatedly betrayed. Nor can a society claim to value human life while allowing commercial greed to endanger the health of ordinary people. The administration must understand that food safety is not a seasonal issue that attracts attention only when a scandal breaks out. It is a continuous public responsibility.
If the government does not wake up now, investigate the entire network, regulate the rapidly expanding food business and establish a credible system of accountability, such incidents will continue to return. The real test of governance is not how many kilograms of rotten meat are seized after a tip-off, but how effectively the system prevents unsafe food from reaching people’s plates in the first place.
Kashmir needs more than condemnations, press statements and temporary inspection drives. It needs a food safety system that works every day, holds the powerful and the small equally accountable, and places human life above commercial profit. Otherwise, every new scandal will be followed by the same outrage, the same promises and, eventually, another dangerous consignment.

